Is My Patient Faking It?
Unfortunately, correctional nurses must be wary of a variety of motives behind inmate-patients seeking medical or mental health treatment. Malingering is defined as the intentional falsification or exaggeration of symptoms for external motives or secondary gain. There is a high incidence of malingering in jails and prisons. A reported 20% of mental illness in corrections is malingering.
Reasons to Fake Illness
There are many reasons an inmate may fake a mental or medical condition. The first that usually comes to mind is to procure drugs. Separated from preferred mood enhancers such as alcohol or barbiturates, inmates seek other avenues of relief. Seroquel (Suzie-Q) is an example of a current favorite that may be sought through feigning mental illness or psychosis.
However, in the prison system secondary gain can include other, more benign desires such as special creams, lotions, or supplements. One prison system I worked in had a problem with overuse of nutritional supplements (such as Ensure). It was discovered that it brought a high price on the facility black market as bodybuilders thought it would help them bulk up.
Illness can also bring desirable housing locations or work release. Trips to hospital or specialists provide avenues for escape attempts or a chance for a ‘vacation’.
Some inmates may exaggerate symptoms because they think they will not get attention in the system unless they are in severe distress. A true medical condition exists but not as intense as it is being portrayed.
A Nurse’s Best Response
A good principle to follow is to “Trust no one but give everyone the benefit of the doubt”. This is key to maintaining the right level of professional objectivity, writes Melissa Caldwell, PhD, in a recent article for the Society of Correctional Physicians. Here are some tips to help you maintain objectivity in the face of potential malingering:
- Do a complete nursing assessment. Do not disregard any medical complaint as faking. Always respond.
- Thoroughly document all objective and subjective data. Repeated questioning now or later may reveal inconsistencies or validate findings.
- Review prior documentation and history for comparison or evidence of drug-seeking behaviors.
- Portray empathy. You do, in fact, want to get to the bottom of the issue and provide correct treatment.
- Avoid giving clues that will make them a better malingerer.
- Err on the side of safety. Provide a period of observation (such as in the infirmary or holding area).
- Always question yourself. After 3 false ‘chest pain’ complaints – this could be the real one.
Remember, determining malingering is not a nursing function. Assessment, referral or treatment based on protocol are nursing actions. As in the game of baseball – play your position.
Why It‘s Important
Getting to the bottom of potential malingering is important in order to eliminate the waste of valuable resources and time that could be more effectively used elsewhere. Correctional nurses can help eliminate inmate malingering by taking careful histories and assessments, documenting responses for comparisons over time, and collaborating with medical and mental health staff to develop appropriate interventions.
More Resources on Malingering
Lockup Doc http://lockupdoc.com/tag/malingering
All Nurse: http://allnurses.com/correctional-nursing/print256963.html
CorrDoc: http://www.corrdocs.org/framework.phppagetype=newsstory&newsid=12160&bgn=2
Lawofficer.com: http://www.lawofficer.com/news-and-articles/columns/Kulbarsh/malingering.html
Journal of Family Practice: http://www.jfponline.com/Pages.asp?AID=2821#1
Psychopharmacology: http://www.acbhcs.org/Psychopharmacology/2005/June2005.pdf
Prison Tattoos – What Nurses Need to Know
Tattoos have been a part of prison culture for some time. Prison tattoos are most often obtained to identify allegiance to a particular gang. Tattoos (also called Tats or Ink) can identify skills, specialties, or convictions. Read about ways tats communicate information. Tattooing is usually forbidden in the prison system, making it a daring task, as well as making it a potentially dangerous one.
Dangers of Prison Tattooing
The major danger of prison tattooing (aside from bad art work!) is blood-born pathogen (BBP) transmission. Typical methods for tattooing include use of common ball-point pen ink and crude make-shift needles. Sterilization is not performed between uses. Although most inmates fear HIV transmission, the most likely BBP is Hepatitis B. The Hepatitis B virus is extremely contagious. Hepatitis C and resulting liver damage can also be transmitted through the prison tattooing process.
A controversial program in Canadian prisons was piloted to decrease the transmission of BBP by employing inmates to provide tattoos within the facility using good technique and sterilized equipment.
Other complications from prison tattooing are allergic reactions to the pigment, aggravation of existing skin diseases, or keloid scarring. You may see these conditions during a sick call visit.
Education Opportunity
Consider adding disease transmission information about prison tattooing during the intake process. Let incoming inmates know of the dangers of submitting to the tattooing process behind bars. Other education opportunities may come during sick call or cell-side rounds. Add tattoo information to regular infection control education and information materials.
Nursing Care Dilemma
An ethical dilemma can ensue if you are asked to assess a tattoo for age. Correctional nurses have been asked to determine if a tattoo is recent (and therefore ‘illegal’). This situation places the nurse in a position to be part of a punitive action. Since correctional nurses must maintain a care-giving status with inmates alternative methods are needed for assessing and staging tattoos within the facility.
How are prison tattoos handled in your workplace? Share your story in the comment section for this post.
Women’s Health in Prison
The number of women in prison is much less than men, however, the rate of growth of female prisoners is nearly double that of males in the US. From 1995 to 2002 the female inmate population grew by 42% and is the fastest growing prison population. Currently 7% of the US prison population and 12% of the jail population is female. Gender issues must be considered in correctional healthcare. Women inmates have increase need for healthcare.
Trauma Informed Care
As many as 57% of women inmates have been physically or sexually abused at some point in their lives. This trauma contributes to increase in depression, stress & anxiety disorders, learning problems, behavioral disorders, and substance abuse according to NCCHC. The trauma-informed approach recognizes trauma as a central issue in the health of the majority of women inmates. Sensitivity and acknowledgement of a traumatic history can lead to interventions promoting recovery.
Mental Health
Trauma and abuse coupled with drug and alcohol abuse lead to increase mental illness. 36% of women inmates are treated for some form of mental illness compared to 24% of men. Correctional nurse working in women’s prisons experience first-hand the increased medication administration, esp. psychotropics, for female inmates. Women inmates are more willing to seek out counseling and psychiatric services, although many facilities are under staffed in these area.
Pregnancy and Reproductive Health
Incarcerated women tend to have complicated and high risk pregnancies due to their past medical histories, lack of prenatal care, and drug/alcohol use. Reproductive health is jeopardized by increased sexually transmitted diseases, pelvic inflammatory disease, and poor hygiene. Inadequate attention to female-specific screenings such as breast exams and Pap smears can lead to undetected cancers.
Impact of Prison on Health
A study in the UK found that imprisonment was largely detrimental to women’s health for a number of reasons. The shock of imprisonment coupled with separation from family and children affected health, as did poor health habits such as lack of exercise, poor dietary choices and close proximity to smokers.
What other female-specific health conditions have you seen in corrections?
Save Healthcare $$$ – Deliver Care Behind the Walls

Prison Tower, Joliet, IL
A West Virginia jail is discovering what many county and state governments have confirmed – inmate healthcare is less expensive when delivered onsite rather than in the community. Why is that? Lets discuss the factors that make onsite healthcare efficient and effective for the corrections community.
Officer Manpower
The greatest savings, by far, in delivering care, treatment and diagnostics behind the security wall of the prison or jail is sheer manhours. Every time an inmate must leave the facility, officers need to attend them, often putting the facility into overtime mode. More than one officer may be needed to deal with transportation, shackles, and continuous observation. Consider the round-the-clock needs while caring for an inmate in a hospital setting. Some states reduce costs by having a locked unit within the hospital which can decrease manpower needs. A few states have an entire prison hospital and/or long-term care facility within a security perimeter.
Telemedicine Behind Bars
A popular way to increase the specialty care delivered behind bars is the use of telemedicine. Televideo equipment beam the specialty practitioner into the facility to dialog with the inmate-patient and the facility medical staff. This operation is most effective for specialty areas like infectious diseases (ongoing management of HIV/HCV) and psychiatry. More sophisticated equipment has been developed to allow accurate assessment of heart and lungs, but they can be ost-prohibitive.
Mobile Diagnostic Units
Another way care is coming to the inmates rather than transporting the inmates to the care is through mobile units. X-rays, Mammography, MRI, and CT Scan Units are now available to come to the facility. Secure outlets from the facility to the mobile unit are arranged and staffed during special periods of operation.
Healthcare is a major component of any Department of Corrections budget. The recent Pew Report on America’s prisons cites an average of 6.8% of state budgets goes toward corrections. Investigating methods to deliver effective and efficient healthcare within the walls is a priority.
Nursing Care During a Prison Riot
The recent prison riot in Chino, CA brings to mind the need for a well prepared nursing staff to handle mass casualties. According to reliable reports, 250 inmates were injured, 55 seriously.
What is the role of the correctional nurse in a riot?
Correctional healthcare staff prepare regularly for a mass casualty situation. In an accredited facility, a prison-wide disaster drill is enacted annually to review the processes and skills necessary to deal with a large influx of injuries. An area of the prison (possibly a rec area or exercise yard) would be designated to triage the victims. Once this area has been secured, correctional nurses provide immediate emergency evaluation and treatment to the inmates brought there by custody staff. They make determinations about the need to transport to a hospital based on degree of injury.
What other challenges for care delivery exist due to a riot?
A common practice during periods of unrest in a correctional facility is the practice of lockdown. Facility lockdown severly restricts inmate movement and communication. This standard procedure for containment reduces the chances for further violence but is a severe stress on manpower and normal processes. Increased security services are required and often increased healthcare staff are needed, as well. Since inmate movement is limited, normal healthcare processes like sick call and medication administration must take place cell-to-cell rather than having inmates travel to the medical unit. Facilities may not be set up to accommodate medication carts in the housing units and pills may have to be ‘pre-poured’ which increases the potential for errors. Diabetic’s insulin injections are now given on the cell block requiring transport of needles and vials. Privacy becomes an issue for various treatments and assessments.
What protection do healthcare staff have during a riot situation?
Prisons and jails are arranged to contain or separate various areas within the security parimeter, usually using a sally port system. Sally ports, strictly monitored and operating by custody staff, greatly increasing protection in an emergency situation. Inmate and staff movement is totally curtailed during the immediate danger. Once the violence is subdued and contained, staff members would be escorted in and out of the building.
In addition, once it is determined which inmates were the leaders of the riot, they will likely be transferred to different facilities to reduce communication, collusion, and/or retaliation.
A prison riot is an emergency situation requiring the skilled intervention of correctional nurses to assess and manage trauma victims. Custody officers and healthcare staff work together to deal with the emergency.
Elderly Inmates – Increasing the Need for Correctional Nurses
With the current economic woes, governments are looking at ways to trim costs. The burgeoning correctional system is one place being reviewed. Upwards of 25% of a state’s budget may be allocated to this concern. However it is unlikely that much can be spared from correctional healthcare budgets. Costs have been escalating for many reasons, not a small one is the increasing age of the inmate population. Information in this blog post comes from two excellent articles. The Council of State Governments published a report – Graying Prisons. Dr. Glenda Reimer’s extensively referenced article The Graying of the U.S. Prisoner Population appeared in the July, 2008 issue of the Journal of Correctional Health Care.
The Extent of the Problem
The elderly inmate (defined as over 50 years of age) is the fastest growing segment of the incarcerated US population. The National Institute of Corrections documents a 172.6% increase in the decade ending 2001 when a total of 113,000 inmates had this designation. This growth is expected to continue for many reasons including longer sentencing, the general aging of the US population as a whole, and get-tough-on-crime reforms.
An Aging Inmate is Older than You Think![]()
Due to a tendency toward poor dietary and exercise habits, coupled with high levels of substance abuse, the inmate population has a physiologic age an average of seven to ten years older than chronological age. This is exacerbated by a general lack of access to health-care services and a poorer socio-economic background than the general public. In fact, a study by the Florida Department of Corrections found, in 2000, that two-thirds of the inmates surveyed had their first significant health care experience while in prison.
Most Common Chronic Conditions Affecting the Older Inmate
Elderly inmates have high levels of chronic illness that must be managed within the security environment. A study by the National Institute of Corrections found these conditions of greatest frequency:
- Arthritis
- Hypertension
- Ulcer Disease
- Prostate Problems
- Myocardial Infarction
Correctional Nursing Needed More Than Ever!
The increasing percentage of aging inmates and their corresponding chronic disease load is requiring an increase in need for correctional nurses. Government statistics do not seem to be kept on current and projected employment in correctional nursing. This needs rectified. Inquiries are in process.
Nurses are needed to provide patient education, medication compliance counseling, and management of the care coordination necessary to deliver chronic care is a security environment.
Systemically, some state governments have initiated designated facilities for housing long-term care and acute care delivery in a centralized fashion. Concentrating healthcare services can lead to cost savings overtime, but can be expensive to initiate.
The need for dedicated quality nursing care to the incarcerated population is great. This specialty nursing practice needs attention and increased visibility.





