This episode was recorded live from the national conference of the American Correctional Health Services Association (ACHSA) in San Antonio, TX. The episode includes commentary from regular panelist, Catherine Knox, MN, RN, CCHP-RN, an independent consultant with nursing and leadership experience in the Oregon Department of Corrections, the Washington Department of Corrections, and California Prison Health Care Services. Also commenting is Gayle Burrows, RN, BSN, MPH, CCHP, recently retired Director of Corrections Health at Multnomah County Detention Center in Portland, OR. Both panelists are active in ACHSA and have received the Distinguished Service Award from the association.
Ethical Issue for Correctional Nurses is the theme this month with several articles highlighting the unique dilemmas we can face.
By Robert GehrkeThe Salt Lake Tribune SALT LAKE, Utah – When a 19-year-old inmate starved to death in his jail cell, Salt Lake County Sheriff Jim Winder said it pointed to a clear need for a way to allow jailers to forcibly feed or hydrate an inmate on at least a short-term basis.
After a 19-year-old inmate starved to death in his cell in Salt Lake County Jail, the Utah State Legislature passed a bill allowing jailers to forcibly feed or hydrate an inmate on at least a short-term basis. Correctional nurses are involved in monitoring the health of these striking inmates and may have ethical conflicts in participating in forcibly feeding an unwilling patient. Panelists discuss ethic issues involving patient autonomy.
Isolation and Seclusion
Amnesty International has accused the Arizona Prison System of abuse in the use of isolation and seclusion interventions. They claim that Arizona’s state prisons overuse solitary confinement in cruel, inhumane and illegal ways, particularly for mentally ill prisoners and juveniles as young as 14. Correctional nurses monitor the health of confined inmates and provide medications and needed treatments while they are secluded. This may lead to the observation of degrading treatment and moral distress in participating in the functions of these confinements.
Restraint Chairs and Pepper Spray
When he left his home in Ohio to visit his brother in Fort Myers, Fla. in March 2009, Nick Christie was already breaking down, physically and mentally. His wife Joyce was concerned about his well-being. Rightly so.
A combative and uncooperative 62-year-old Ohioan arrested in Florida for public intoxication died after repeated pepper spraying and a forceful take-down to a restraint chair. Correctional nurses are called upon to review medical charts for contraindications for use-of-force. Participation in these procedures, even peripherally from a medical perspective, can be unsettling and distressing.
The following documents were discussed as guides for correctional nurses grappling with ethical dilemmas in jails and prisons:
The Nurses Code of Ethics: http://www.nursingworld.org/codeofethics
The International Council of Nurses Position Statement: http://www.icn.ch/images/stories/documents/publications/position_statements/A13_Nurses_Role_Detainees_Prisoners.pdf
The Corrections Nursing Scope and Standards of Practice: http://www.nursesbooks.org/Table-of-Contents/Standards/Corrections-Nursing-Scope-and-Standards-of-Practice.aspx